Independent left newsContactSupport our work
The Explainer

Kansas Said No to the Money and to Trump's Name

The pattern is plain in the returns. Across the country, Democrats dominated the elections while Donald Trump, a lame-duck Republican, waged an unpopular war on Iran — a war his own administration has now walked away from negotiating, with Trump signaling an end to the talks led by his vice president. But the sharpest story is not the national mood. It is the machinery built to stop these results, and how it failed anyway. Look at Kansas, and you watch money and power lose a fight they stacked in advance.

Kansas is not a swing state in the usual sense. It goes reliably Republican in presidential elections, even as its voters often break for Democrats in the midterms. That split matters: the party machinery had every structural advantage and spent accordingly. State Senator Cindy Holscher won the governor's race anyway, and not by matching her opponent dollar for dollar. She overcame a flood of money that Republicans poured behind Ty Masterson, the president of the GOP-controlled state Senate.

Masterson was no outsider. He ran the chamber. He had the party's institutional weight, he had the donor class behind him, and he had Trump's endorsement as the more well-known Republican in the race. Name recognition, presidential backing, and a wall of cash — the three things supposed to decide a contest in Republican-leaning terrain. He lost with all of them.

What makes Kansas an argument rather than an accident is what Holscher ran on. She promised to halt new data centers. That is not a culture-war abstraction. Data centers are the physical plant of capital's current boom — vast warehouses that swallow land, electricity and water and funnel public subsidies into private server farms. A candidate who says she will stop them draws a line directly between the households that pay the utility bill and the firms building their profits on top of it. The money against her was not random generosity; it was an interest with something concrete to lose.

So the Kansas fight was legible: organized money and a borrowed presidential brand on one side, a pledge to stop capital's build-out on the other. The money side lost. That is the lesson national coverage flattens when it talks only of a Democratic wave.

Mississippi makes the point from the opposite end of the map. Scott Colom won the Senate race there after a razor-tight battle with Cindy Hyde-Smith. The state is not supposed to be competitive for the left under any circumstance. That it went to the wire tells you entrenched power there is weaker than it looks, in a place it has governed almost unchallenged for a generation.

And the money never stops working. Even as it lost these races, the machine kept buying: in Washington, lawmakers are now pressing Trump's fundraiser Meredith O'Rourke to explain the terms of donors' gifts to Trump's ballroom and other pet projects. That is what the cash is for — access, and the return it expects.

Who it costs is the point. The build-out Holscher campaigned against makes its profits when a compliant governor waves it through and sends the bill to Kansas households. Her opponent had the money; he did not get the office. The lesson for the organized left is not that money is harmless. It is that money can be beaten when the line between who pays and who profits is drawn plainly enough for voters to see it.