Independent left newsContactSupport our work
The Explainer

They Tried to Silence Palestine Solidarity. It Didn't Work.

Two things are happening at once, and they are the same thing. At home, the machinery of repression has spent the past period trying to break the movement for Palestinian lives. Abroad, Palestinian-Americans are learning that the same government offers them nothing. A Palestinian-American watched Israeli soldiers occupy their home for weeks and trash it, and the U.S. government did nothing to help. The thread binding the two is a single preference of power: silence the people who object, and abandon the people who suffer.

Start with the abandonment, because it is the most naked. When the family turned to Washington, they were told to confront the soldiers themselves. The account is spare: "They told us to confront the soldiers ourselves, and when my husband did, he was pushed, threatened with arrest, and tear gassed." That is the whole arrangement in one sentence. A citizen asks their own government for protection against a foreign army occupying their property; the government hands them back to that army. The passport means nothing when the occupier is a client state and the occupied is Palestinian.

And the state keeps that client funded. Even after the administration claimed otherwise, reports say Trump lied about ending aid to Israel, and officials are working to renew the funding for another five or ten years. The occupation that wrecked that home runs on money Washington will not stop sending. That is the context for the shrug: the soldiers in the house and the dollars behind them are the same policy.

Now turn to the silencing, which is more bureaucratic but no less deliberate. The crackdown leaned on universities to do the disciplinary work — the suspensions, the no-contact orders, the police on the quad. It worked, up to a point. The crackdowns diminished campus organizing, thinning out the visible protest that had made administrators nervous. If the measure of success were the number of encampments, power could claim a win.

But that is not the measure, and the strategists who bet on it miscalculated. Repression that isolates students on campus does not kill a political movement; it pushes it off campus and into the city, where there is no dean to lean on. The broader movement has continued to grow. The institutions meant to contain the organizing instead advertised its stakes.

You can see the movement that outlasted the crackdown by looking at who is still standing after four decades of this work. Brooklyn for Peace marked 42 years of activism at an annual gala that honored Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, a pair of pro-Palestine legal organizations and a tenacious Staten Island peace activist. The detail that matters most is succession: the event was emceed by the group's new, 29-year-old executive director. A movement handing leadership to people in their twenties is not being silenced. It is preparing for the long fight.

Put the pieces beside each other and the strategy comes into focus. The legal organizations honored in Brooklyn exist precisely because families like the one whose home was occupied are told to fend for themselves. The campus crackdown, the maintained funding, the diplomatic shrug are not separate failures; they are the domestic and foreign faces of one policy — protect the occupation, isolate its critics, offer Palestinians the back of the hand.

What it means is simpler than the officials pretending otherwise would like. The repression was supposed to end the argument. Instead it clarified it. The cost falls where it always falls: on the family handed back to the soldiers, on the students disciplined for naming what their government funds, on the organizers who keep rebuilding what the state keeps trying to tear down. They bet that the silence would not hold. So far, they are winning that bet.