Trump Sits Down With Strongmen, Puts Allies on the Table
The pattern is no longer arguable. On Thursday the president of the United States sat down in China with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping for what reporters described as an unprecedented meeting between the leaders of the US, China and Russia. The venue was a secluded resort in Shenzhen, the Kylin Villa that once hosted the North Korean dictator Kim Jong-il. The framing on offer was triumphal: making history. Strip the pageantry and what you have is the most powerful office in the capitalist world convened with the two governments it spent years naming as its chief rivals, with nobody in the room to speak for the people whose futures were on the agenda.
And a great deal was on the agenda. The three men began talks to discuss Iran, trade and Russia's war with Ukraine. Read that list again. A war of occupation, the terms of global trade, and the fate of a sanctioned state, taken up by three leaders accountable to no electorate that could reach them. These are not abstractions. Trade terms are jobs and prices. A war is bodies. When power sits with power, the subjects of the conversation become line items.
This is not a stumble. The Los Angeles Times called the sitdown the culmination of a decade of his foreign policy thinking, elevating authoritarian leaders over democratic allies. That is the thread, and the administration backs the preference up with pressure. It spent months leaning on Denmark over Greenland, with Trump repeatedly insisting the US should take control of the island. Strongmen get flattery; allies get shaken down. The summit is the arc arriving at its destination, not a detour from it.
The machinery underneath it is personal, and the president does not hide it. He calls Putin and Xi friends and treats his willingness to engage authoritarian leaders as a virtue. Ahead of the trilateral he met Putin alone and said the two have a great relationship. His critics put the danger more plainly, warning the approach could let them exploit his appetite for adoration. Two governments that have studied him for a decade, invited to flatter a man whose foreign policy runs on flattery. The leverage in that room does not run the way the cameras suggest.
Nor is the alarm confined to think-tank liberals. One investigation laid it out: Trump may imagine he is walking into another episode of a reality show, where he can bluster, bluff, bully, and ultimately declare himself the winner. But a summit is not television, and the counterparts are not contestants. The men across the table hold states, armies and economies, and they came with their own plans. The performance of dominance and the possession of it are not the same thing, and the gap between them is where ordinary people get hurt.
So who pays? The reporting hands us no casualty count from Shenzhen, and inventing one would be its own lie. But the agenda names the targets without ceremony. Ukrainians under a war now being bargained across a table. Working people on every side of a trade settlement they had no voice in shaping. The allies this administration has spent a decade demoting, from Copenhagen outward, now watching three men redraw the terms of their security without them. Refuse the spectacle. This was not statesmanship and it was not peace. It was the consolidation of power talking to power, conducted in public, and the measure of it will not be the handshake photographs but the bill that lands later on people who were never invited to the room.